Are Citizens One Loans Trustworthy and Worth It? Real Experiences & Red Flags

Based on my research, Citizens One shows many red flags and mixed experiences, so its trustworthiness is questionable.

I have not used the company myself; I only looked at publicly available reviews and information. The feedback is heavily weighted toward negative experiences, with only one positive comment.

Most reviewers complain about customer service. One person who worked in collections described a chaotic internal system: different departments do not share data, so you must repeat the same information on every call. Issues can take a month to be reflected in the reporting system, leaving customers in the dark about balances and payment status.

Common problems mentioned:

  • Repeated transfers and long hold times – callers are often put on hold for 30‑60 minutes, then transferred to another department that may not be open.
  • Lack of proactive communication – customers are not notified of missed autopayments or account changes. Emails may be blocked, and the company does not follow up by phone or mail.
  • Billing errors – several users received unexpected charges (e.g., $79 for a denied iPhone loan, $33.95 after a car loan was paid off, $39 for a phantom bill). When they called, representatives were unwilling or unable to resolve the issue, sometimes hanging up.
  • Collections tactics – some say the collections team lies about payment arrangements, forces you to call a representative to make a payment, and refuses to accept payments that were previously agreed upon.
  • Confusing early‑payment rules – one reviewer was told early payments are illegal, then given contradictory explanations about how the payment was applied.

A few reviewers noted a positive side:

  • One borrower received a $50,000 loan with an 8.73 % APR, which was lower than offers from SoFi, Upgrade, Upstart, Earnest, LendingClub, and LightStream.
  • The loan was approved the next day, with no origination fee.
  • The application process was described as fast and required only reasonable verification.

The only downside mentioned for this positive experience was a clunky online portal where uploaded documents did not appear immediately and the status lagged behind reality.

Key takeaways

  • Customer service appears to be the biggest weakness. Long hold times, poor communication, and unhelpful staff are repeatedly reported.
  • Billing and account errors seem common, and getting them fixed can be difficult.
  • Loan terms can be competitive (e.g., 8.73 % APR, no origination fee) for borrowers who qualify.
  • Internal processes are fragmented, leading to delays in updating account information.

Given the prevalence of complaints about service and billing, you should weigh these concerns against the potentially attractive loan rates. The decision to proceed with Citizens One is ultimately yours.
 
Back
Top